So much of modern advice for teachers involves tuning in to students’ anxieties, fears, and moods in such a way that you are told, “Never cold-call a student,” or “Don’t give a student anxiety by asking them to read an unfamiliar passage out loud.”
I think this is a misdirected or perhaps misapplied approach to considering students’ feelings. While I never seek to actively increase a student’s anxiety, I believe that there is a value in productive discomfort. For example, if you call on a student to read a passage aloud, the “considerate” approach (advised above) would say, give them time to prepare so they don’t embarrass themselves. However, I think we are targeting the wrong feeling here: why should there be embarrassment? If they make a mistake, it is an opportunity for the class to reflect on
a) what the “mistake” actually means,
b) why the student made it, and
c) how to recover from it.
What I mean is, when we only allow learning opportunities that cater to students’ feelings of ease and calm, we are showing them that the world will give them ease and calm. When we give a student a challenging academic task and stand beside them through that task, we are showing them that these feelings of anxiety and fear can be accommodated — that a resilient learner accepts the negative feelings and works with them.
I believe that learning should be enjoyable and safe, and I do agree that students learn best in a trusting environment. However, rigor and difficulty are not the absence of trust. It is a sign of trust if someone believes I can do a difficult task and stands beside me while I do it…rather than watering down the task until I am comfortable with each stage.
Life after school will not wait for you to feel calm before throwing crap at you. Building a supportive and loving classroom means establishing non-negotiable rules of civility in the presence of difficulty, not the absence of it.
This post is part of The Learning Curve, my column on teaching and learning. In these posts, I’ll share experiences and research from college and high school teaching.




Leave a Reply